Why must new owners pay membership fees that previous
owners failed to pay?
When someone buys a platted lot in Cripple Creek Mountain Estates, the person
who buys the lot automatically acquires the prior owner's membership (if it hasn’t been
forfeited) -- together with any outstanding obligations attached to that membership --
in MMWC. See C.R.S. § 7-42-104(4) (providing that the shares of stock in a ditch
company "shall be ... transferable ... in the manner provided by the bylaws); MMWC
Bylaws, Art. V, Section 2 (providing for automatic transfer of membership upon sale of a
platted lot in CCME).
However, the transfer of a membership from one owner to the next does not
expunge the fees owed by that membership. State law gives mutual ditch companies a
"perpetual lien" against the membership -- not the lot itself -- for any and all charges
owed. See C.R.S. § 7-42-104(3) ("[S]uch corporation shall have a perpetual lien upon
such shares of stock and the water rights represented by the same for any and all such
assessments until the same are fully paid. Such corporation may also provide that no
water shall be delivered until all assessments are paid"). If those fees are not paid by
the new owner, MMWC can avail itself of a number of legal remedies, including refusing
to provide water or water service, suit for payment of delinquent fees, and/or forfeiture
of the membership. See Delinquencies page.
Moreover, the lien against the membership survives a tax sale or foreclosure
proceeding. This is because the property rights a buyer acquires in a lot are separate
from the connection rights associated with a membership. See C.R.S. § 7-42-104(4)
(providing that the shares of stock in a ditch company "shall be deemed personal
property").
If a prospective buyer of a CCME lot retains the services of a responsible title
company, the title company will contact MMWC to find out if any outstanding fees are
owed. If a prospective buyer chooses not to retain the services of a title company, it is
incumbent on that buyer to do his or her own due diligence.
Copyright © 2009-2011 MMWC Director Eric W. Cernyar